Music and the early Irish Church
Date
2024-04-16Embargo Date
2026-04-16
Author
Marzolla, Maria Chiara
Metadata
Show full item recordUsage
This item's downloads: 0 (view details)
Abstract
The project’s aim is to reconstruct the conceptualization of music in the context of early
medieval Irish ecclesiastical education through a systematic analysis of the influence of
the Church Fathers on Hiberno-Latin literature, ca. 600–900. Moreover, a comparison
between the representation of music in religious and secular literary sources has been
carried out, to shed new light on the role of music in the various strata of Early Medieval
Irish society.
Since no Irish sources with musical notation are extant prior to the twelfth century,
literary sources necessarily have provided the bulk of the evidence: it has been therefore
essential to examine them thoroughly and create a catalogue with each reference to music
traceable in the Hiberno-Latin sources, in order to reconstruct the theorization of music
by the medieval Irish literati, as well as to define the conflict between the secular view of
music and the ecclesiastical one—the latter being influenced by the tradition of the
Church Fathers, which was very much hostile to the notion of music as a source of
aesthetic pleasure.
We already know that the writings of some Fathers of the Church (such as Augustine
and Jerome) had a profound impact on biblical exegesis in Ireland: my research traces
this influence in Hiberno-Latin literature as to the specific domain of music, both vocal
and instrumental. For example, my work deals with the early Irish grammarians and their
difficulty to classify the sound of musical instrument inside a precise category of uox and
sonus. It also examines the various symbolic meanings often associated with singing,
exploring the patristic origin of such symbols and allegories. A comparison with some
vernacular sources has also been carried out.
The thesis also investigates Hiberno-Latin sources that include references to the topic
of teaching and learning music, demonstrating the existence of texts that adopted a
sophisticated vocabulary to discuss chant and sound in the ecclesiastical context.
Finally, my investigation describes how musical instruments were considered and
treated in Hiberno-Latin sources, from three main perspectives: (1) as part of musica
disciplina (one of the liberal arts); (2) with reference to actual musical performance; and
(3) as bearers of allegories or symbolic significance.